however, the cabin used where Ben was holding Abigail was not. That one was described as a "secluded cabin," and never was meant to be the Horton one on Smith Island. Hope even said aloud that they were going to the Horton cabin, and commented how good it felt to be back there. If it wasn’t the Horton cabin, why would it have had the picture of Tom and Alice there? Of course, it’s probably all the same set with simple adjustments to moveable walls and furniture, and now a reference to an "upstairs."