Home Forums Salem Place: The Main Board Mel as Carly’s daughter

Viewing 9 posts - 16 through 24 (of 24 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #9728
    IzzyB
    Participant

    Mel and Mia are NOT the same age at all.  Mia is in High School and Mel is in Nursing school.  So there has to be 2 -3 years difference between the two.  Why wouldn’t Vivian find out Mia’s age and see it doesn’t match when Carly gave birth?!?

    #9729
    IzzyB
    Participant

    I think it will throw a wrench into Vivian’s plans.  And I think Carly knows for sure, if it isn’t Mel, it can’t be Mia.  The age difference would give it away.  Carly knows when she gave birth to this baby.

    #9730
    IzzyB
    Participant

    The Dr. Dan being the father seems a stretch.  Since Carly did introduce Dr. Dan to his wife, were they romantically involved?  Also, wouldn’t Carly know since she slept with this one doctor, who the father is?  Don’t you think she would say something to Bo about the father too? 

    #9732
    IzzyB
    Participant

    I for one don’t think it is Dr. Dan.  It is all speculation.

    #9736
    spoiled
    Participant

    That’s a good point.  I would put Melanie’s age right now at around 19-20 and Mia’s at 15-16; that’s a pretty decent time stretch for giving birth. Wouldn’t Vivian know this, too?  Or did she just now find out that Carly has a kid?  I’m not sure.

    #9739
    ellenkb
    Participant

    How else would he have gotten her?  And why would he want her if she wasn’t his kid?  I have already forgotten – did Lawrence take the baby away from her and give her away?  This is one convoluted SL!

    #9742
    53tdogs
    Participant

    Lawrence forced her to give her baby away – (which is as good as him taking the baby away).  Yes!  It would be so much better if they gave us more background – especially – since they have made it a major story line.  Details writers!  We want details!

     

    #9747
    IzzyB
    Participant

    Carly said that Lawrence forced her to give the baby to that awful man.  She specifically said that, which I took as she was forced to give the baby to Trent.  So Trent could be the father and she later realized how bad of a person he was and didn’t want to give the baby to him.

    #9765
    SW
    Participant

     as the saying goes, "This is Days!"  Time warps seem to be constants with this show.  

Viewing 9 posts - 16 through 24 (of 24 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.