- This topic has 15 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 14 years, 8 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Well I dont know about anybody else but I kinda like Stephanie and Melanie when they are not friends rather then when they "are" friends, it was too forced. they seem much better when they cant stand each other! LOL
I can’t stand Stephanie, period! ugh! I’m so hoping that one day, when Melanie administers a TKO on her!
I would like to see that, too.
However, I am afraid that Stephanie and her big mouth may have delivered a ‘death blow’ to Philip and Melanie’s relationship. I don’t like Stephanie at all; she is too needy.
Goody
Stephanie is beautiful but "hello" no one is home, she’s either clueless or conniving…there’s no in between or happiness in her. I usually FF’d through her scenes…I didn’t like Mel when she first come on board, and there’s been a few times with her whining little girl stuff, but at least she has more range and likeablity. Stephanie is one-dimensional.
I can’t stand Stephanie. I find nothing in her that evokes either my sympathies or empathy.
Melanie on the other hand, I find to be an interesting character. And I think the actress does a good job with the material.
Actually I like Stephanie, I can’t understand why she would ever be friends with Melanie….Why? she has been a pest to her ever since they met. All the wrong things Melanie has done and not much a word said about how selfish or coneiving she’s been. But as soon as Stephanie even looks like she’s thinking something she shouldn’t, others are ready to jump on her for it. Let’s be real! I put myself in her place…and my fiance finds he has a long lost sister…sure,I’d want to help him find her, and if she turns out to be a user and a snot…I’d have a problem with it too and I’d let him know about it. Then every situation there after, I’d understand how she wouldn’t trust her on much of anything . Geesh! Melanie’s managed to rid Stephanie of her relationship with Max, Philip,& Nathan. Even on her wedding day to Philip she wants Stephanie to deliver a message to Nathan to make sure he has the feelings for her she has for him so she can have both guys fighting over her!!!! She is a spoiled selfish misguided immature lolita! Thankgoodness Maggie has had a good influence on her or she’d be intolerable! I’m not saying there is no hope….but it escapes me how alot of people don’t have sympathy for Stephanie and what she has endured at Melanie’s hands. Don’t get me wrong…I’ve grown to like her at times despite the over animated expressions and over the top acting, she’s trying real hard to be perky and fun…..but it’s hard for me to forget all the drama she was involved with and all the unfortunate circumstances that occured because of it. Nick’s in jail for murder,& lost his fuel project, Max’s royalities are gone & the plans he fixed for the project…Tony’s dead, Philip got shot, Stephanie was kidnapped & hooked on drugs, Stefano was held hostage and in a comma (ok, we can get over that) Anna’s a widow,and Titian lost lots of money,and we can go on & on. And I wish the writters WOULD give Stephanie a little more to work with since Melanie’s character is on EVERY day…& Carly….WE DO have others we’d like to see more than the "newer" ones all the time!
sorry for the rant….I’m just not on the Mealnie bandwagon.
I thought I was the only Stephanie fan and I couldn’t believe how disliked she is. I’ve also found she has been justified in mostt of her actions. I loved how she told Mel she didn’t regret anything she did. I don’t find her whiney at all. I wonder if there are any more of us out there.
I think it’s safe to say it’s just the two of ya! Stephanie is pure evil! She’s JEALOUS of Melanie because all the hot guys (in their age bracket) slobber over her, and no one really cares two breath mints for her (Steph)! She is sooooo pathetic! Why would she even want to be with a guy (Nate) that she KNOWS darn well will drop her like a hot skillet if and when Melanie says "Okay. You can be my man now."?! She’s so dumb! That’s just part of the reason why I don’t like her. {Note: the only time I truly liked the Stephanie character was when the red-head played the role.} She knows that Melanie is totally a force to be rekoned with! She’s just a spoiled lil’ brat who’s used to getting all the attention…NOT THIS TIME!S Ugh! I so want Melanie to smack her multiple times across the face, until she wakes up and get a life!
in that they both annoy me to a fault. Are they beautiful girls…yes…beautiful girls whose sole purpose in life is planning to take what the other has instead of concentrating on being happy with the people they claim to love and strong enough to believe they can keep them. They are both lying, manipulative schemers who are gravely jealous of one another, even though they claim they are happy with their lives and the choices they have made (yeah, right); they both use other men to try and make someone jealous. They are both continually looking for ways to get into confrontations with one another to point out the other’s faults (don’t bother…you both suck); Melanie will continue to use Phillip, and now Stephanie will use this poor jerk, Aaron; neither one of them has been able to display any sort of moral compass that shows me they have located the high ground and are now above their childish behavior when it comes to ‘getting even’ with one another; their accusatory debates with one another are a joke, since they may as well be talking to and looking into a mirror when they do come face to face; and, finally, if Phillip or Nathan had an ounce of brains between them, they would tell both of them to take a hike and don’t come back until you’re a grown-up.
I’m amazed that Stephanie is disliked…but hey, to each his own! I guess it’s simular to the Belle/ Mimi debate, I’ve defended Belle to the hilt too…and..guess I was right, Shawn and Belle were back together like the real love birds they were intended to be!
I can see why Stephanie doesn’t like Melanie. I’m not saying she doesn’t have reasons, but if she’s going to act all moral and self-righteous, then she can’t act different to Melanie than she does everyone else, in my opinion. She should own what she did, too.
I don’t think it’s fair to say they are the same, though. Melanie is a big younger than Stephanie I think, had an awful upbringing, basically no good influences, her father was pimping her out just a year or two ago, then killed and she was a prime suspect. Stephanie grew up without a father, but still as a Brady. Not really comparable. At some point you can’t blame your upbringing for bad choices, but I think she’s still trying to find her way.
I like Stephanie also, but I do think they need to give her some sort of storyline that doesn’t involve Philip and/or Nathan! That triangle (quadrangle?) has gone on long enough… give her someone new and how about having a guy throw himself at HER for a change?!?!
I agree, for the past year we’ve had to sit through Melanie/Phillip/Stefanie then Melanie/Nathan/Stefanie and now Melanie/Phillip/Stefanie/Nathan. We need a break from all of them. If you want to count Melanie/Max/Stefanie when they were tearing Max in two trying to make him decide between his sister or his girlfriend those two have been at the center of a triangle/quadrangle long enough.
I do like Stephanie, always have. Melanie on the other hand, IMO is the whiny needy one. I would like to see Stepahine say ‘to heck with all of it’ and walk away from ALL of them. I guarentee Nathan and Phillip BOTH would be trying to ‘woo’ her back!
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.